Reader WMH used the website's "Contact Me" yesterday (2023-12-12) to inquire:
"Hello Professor Lin, I am a pharmacist and often read your works and articles. Recently, when studying degenerative inflammation, I found that a doctor mentioned that in the treatment guidelines issued by the American Orthopedic Medicine Association in 2022, glucosamine is converted from black red. Some articles are as follows: Dietary supplements such as glucosamine are translated from black red red red. The first two versions of the guidelines believe that glucosamine is supplemented and Solutein has no effect, but the new version of the guidelines believes that some evidence can support the use of dietary supplements such as ginger, ginger extract, glucosamine, solutein, vitamin D to reduce pain and improve function in patients with moderate knee inflammation. Website. Please ask if the above content is true? Thank you! ”The link above opens a blog post, titled: 2022 American Orthopedic Medical Association "Guidelines for Treatment of Degenerative Knee Inflammation": What exactly is the treatment effective? What treatment is ineffective?
This article was published in the blog of Dai Dawei. He is the director of the ward of the Orthopedic Department of Chengda Hospital and the attending physician of the Reconstruction Center of the Department of Reconstruction and Reconstruction Center.
The article does not specify the publication date, but it can be seen that it is the latest article in this blog, which means it should have been published in the past few days. Some of the articles attached to
Reader WMH are copied from this blog post. In other words, Dr. Dai did say that "In the treatment guidelines issued by the American Orthopedic Medicine Association in 2022, glucosamine is transferred from black …… ginger yellow, ginger extract, glucosamine, solutein, vitamin D and other dietary supplements to reduce pain and improve function in patients with mild to moderate knee joint inflammation."
In addition to making such a statement, Dr. Dai also produced a chart showing that ginger yellow, ginger extract, glucosamine, rosin, and vitamin D are "medium certificates" (tris stars).
I downloaded their latest guidance from the American Orthopaedic Medical Association website (posted on 2022-5-1): AAOS Clinical Practice Guideline Summary: Management of Osteoarthritis of the Knee (Nonarthroplasty), Third Edition.
You can also download directly from here: https://www.aaos.org/globalassets/quality-and-practice-resources/osteoarthritis-of-the-knee/oak3cpg.pdf
The evaluation system used in this guide is Strength of Recommendation, not what Dr. Dai calls "certification level". However, we should be able to view "certification level" and "recommendation strength".
Regardless of the matter, there is a chart in the guide that shows that the "recommended strength" of ginger yellow, ginger extract, glucosamine, solutein, vitamin D is "limited" (two stars). Interestingly, the chart also shows that the recommended strength of these replenishing agents is downgrade.
{twenty three} {twenty four}
So, do you say, is it turned from black to black, or is it turned from red?
Or, turn black from gray?
Or, from "Urulu" to "Urulu"?
Original text: Glucosamine is converted from black red, edited by an orthopedic doctor: Gu Zihuan